Lately I’ve been reading Star Wars comics of various types. First, there’s the “Classic Star Wars” trade paperbacks from Dark Horse, which are reprinting the old Marvel comics. Then there’s the “Classic Star Wars” trade paperbacks from Dark Horse, which are reprinting the old newspaper strips. Finally there’s “Star Wars Tales”, a current title from Dark Horse with short stories set at various points in the timeline. And there’s something I’ve noticed about them.
The Marvel comics are great. These came out in 1977 or 1978, just after the first movie came out. The writers had nothing to go on but the first movie, and proceeded to take our heroes on all sorts of adventures, meeting many new friends and foes. In fact, in the first volume of this trade paperback, the Empire doesn’t even appear after the adaptation of the movie. They’re great fun, with all sorts of interesting robots and aliens.
The newspaper strips are equally intriguing. I’m not sure when they came out (they may not be in order) but some of them are set before The Empire Strikes Back, even though they were clearly written afterwards (we see the construction and test-flight of Darth Vader’s super star destroyer, for example.) Again, although the Empire has a more prominent role, we still meet many interesting new friends and foes.
The current ones are, of course, being produced after there are five movies out, and are free to take place at any point in the movie timelines. And strangely, they’re the least interesting. The odd thing is, as huge a universe as they have to work in, all the writers seem intent on making it smaller. That is, instead of branching out in new ways as the Marvel comics or newspaper strips were forced to do, they seem intent on closing in, on bringing different points together. So you’ll see strips where, say, Wedge meets Yoda, or we find out that Kitster built the Millennium Falcon or whatever. The writers seem terrified to bring in anything from outside the “canon,” so they find a Point A and a Point B of existing things and join them together. And the result is sometimes interesting, but often dull.
The prequels (and “Special” Editions) have done this too, to a point. There was no need to Anakin to have built C-3P0. We didn’t need him to live on Tattooine. Seeing little Greedo was unnecessary. And don’t get me started on Boba Fett.
It just seems weird to me. With all this space in which to play, why keep going to the same things over and over? Now I admit that I haven’t followed any of the horrible books that have come out, in which new enemies have been introduced, but I’m looking at these old strips which are so much fun and so much in the spirit of adventure and excitement and the later stuff seems so leaden by comparison. It seems joyless. Which is not to say there aren’t some fun ones or some people getting into the spirit of things, but a lot of them just seem to be going through the motions. What would happen if it turned out a young Ben Kenobi had fought a young Bib Fortuna long ago? The world would get much smaller.